1.4 CHAPTER ONE
A Metaphysics of Metabolism
TABLE OF CONTENTS p

Roots, Seeds, and Indivisibles

The next triad of thinkers had several themes in common. Empedocles, Anaxagoras, and Democritus inherited a tradition of inquiry into the nature of material substance. The tradition had accrued over four generations of intellectual haggling in the marketplace of ideas. Not content to reinvest in monism, these bright young minds bet their fortunes in the hitherto untapped market of pluralism. Each sought to explain the multiplicity of things in the cosmos by supposing each thing a composite of multiple elements, in varied proportion, which were common to all things. Each proposed a different set of elements and, aside from superficial observations, none had a method for obtaining detailed sensory evidence. Empedocles declared a tetrad of root elements driven by a pair of opposites, Anaxagoras an unlimited wealth of 'seeds', and Democritus an infinite number of indivisibles-- atoms. All agreed that the qualitative differences between things could be explained by the relative quantities of their component elements arranged in a thing. While Empedocles ignored scale, Anaxagoras supposed his seeds could be cut up as small as you like while never losing their potency, and Democritus considered his indivisibles imperceptibly tiny yet very solid bodies.
Empedocles
About the time Parmenides finished his poem of well-rounded truth, Empedocles was born (circa 484 BCE) in a Greek colony on the Island of Sicily, at the city of Akragas. A contemporary of Zeno, but invested in more practical matters, Empedocles developed a successful medical career and eventually established a school of medicine which gained reknown as the Sicilian School. He also wrote a treatise, On Nature, in which he prayed:
"[Beloved Muse, bring me] such words as are right and proper for ephemeral creatures to hear. You will not be urged, by some mortal ambitious to scale the heights of wisdom, to tell more than is fitting. Come now, with all your powers discern how each thing manifests itself, trusting no more to sight than to hearing, and no more to the echoing ear than to the tongue's taste; rejecting none of the body's parts that might be a means to knowledge, but attending to each particular manifestation." 
Figure 1.9
While in support of sensory evidence with Heraclitus and likewise cognizant of cyclic strife, Empedocles also respected the rationale of What Is. With Parmenides, he reasoned that Is must be imperishable. Yet a static pure Is-ness was useless for an explanation of the apparent multiplicity-- the wonderous variety of things-- in the cosmos. So this worthy doctor, master of the art which brings healing from disease, reasoned What Is as manifest in cyclic change. He considered What Is as the ground of "the four roots of all things". It requires "no birth in mortal things, and no end in ruinous death. There is only mingling and interchange of parts, and it is this that we call 'nature'. When these elements are mingled into the shape of a man living under the bright sky, or into the shape of wild beasts or plants or birds, men call it birth: and when these things are separated into their parts men speak of hapless death." The dynamic Is generates reality through a twofold process.
"For at one time there grew to be a single One out of many, while at another time there came to be many by division out of One-- fire, water, earth, and the lofty height of air. Apart from these and in balanced relation to them is dreadful Strife; while Love resides in their midst, throughout their length and breadth."
Figure 1.10

The perpetual recycling of One and many is driven by the two equal but opposing forces, Love and Strife, which now and again by turns gain an upper hand in the mixture of elements rooted in Is. The two forces "are the only things that are; and by interpenetrating they become one thing in one place and another in another. [Such basic things as] sunbeams and earth, sky and sea, [i.e., the four elements] are at one with the parts that compose them, even though thrown in different guises to mortals' apprehension." Whether or not we regard Empedocles' theory as a proper synthesis of the positions advocated by Heraclitus (Becoming) and Parmenides (Being), the lore of Love and Strife had some popular appeal. Besides which, all folk had immediate experience of fire, water, earth and air. 

Importantly, Empedocles was the first to explain particular things as composed with distinct particles of just these four elementals in varied proportion. Perceived qualities could thus be explained quantitatively. "[T]he forms and colors of all mortal things by the unifying power of Aphrodite [arise] out of water, earth, air, and sun [fire], mingled together", and a particular substance is explained as "perhaps with a little more of one [element], a little less of another." Empedocles described bone, for example, as two parts of earth, two parts water, and four parts fire "fitted together with the divine cement of right proportion." (Proportion, of course, harkens back to Pythagoras.)

Without experimental evidence, such schema appeals to the imagination and can be applied to any object of substance. Might not a feather contain six parts air, one part earth, and one part fire? Or flint, eight parts earth and one part fire? Of course, we are never told how to measure one part of an element, be it air or fire, or how to mix them successfully. Yet experience with mundane cookery on the family hearth demonstrates that we do combine earthy stuff with water and fire (which requires air) to produce edible food. Subject only to idle speculation, the four 'roots' of substance were to prove durable as concepts, thanks in no small part to the subsequent refinement and certification of the concepts by Aristotle-- and, the persistence of Aristotle's written works over the millenia.

Indeed, this tetrad of 'elements' was carried forward (from the Mediterranean, throughout Europe) by common knowledge as the key to any comprehension of the material world until disrupted by chemical evidence in the 18th century. Then a series of investigators known loosely as 'pneumatick' chemists isolated different gases, among them several components of air including 'phlogisticated air' (nitrogen), 'fixed air' (carbon dioxide), and a small volume of inert gas (argon). Lavoisier named the "purest part of the air" oxygen and a gas known as 'inflammable air', hydrogen. Then he went on to demonstrate that water is a compound of oxygen and hydrogen while others later showed atmospheric 'air' is a mixture of nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide, water vapor, and argon. Meanwhile, earthy compounds were demystified through the 18th century and thereafter as alchemy slowly matured into analytic chemistry. Fire, however, did not yield its secret until the development of electron theory near the end of the 19th century. Although the doctrine of four elements was broadly propagated for several millenia after the death of Empedocles (circa 424 BCE), there were competing pluralistic theories proffered contemporaneously. Anaxagoras, for example, proposed myriad elements and argued that even air or water are not elemental but indeed, gross manifestations of a finer stuff-- very much finer, as we soon shall see.

Anaxagoras
Born circa 500 BCE in Ionia at the city of Clazomenae (see Figure 1.12, below), just north of Heraclitus' old haunt in Ephesus, Anaxagoras migrated to Athens as a young man to study philosophy. There he established a teaching practice in his maturity, tutoring aristocratic youth. As his career developed, Anaxagoras earned the distinction of being the first philosopher to flourish as a teacher in Athens. Among Anaxagoras' students was the young Pericles, who eventually became a successful political leader, and Euripedes, who later gained reknown as a dramatist.

Anaxagoras was an elder contemporary of Empedocles in faraway Akragas (see Figure 1.9, above). The younger theorist published first but, given Anaxagoras' position in a city-state (Athens) that would generate over the next few generations an Olympian array of philosophical luminaries, we might expect the older man to have had a greater influence. Yet the treatise published by Anaxagoras, On Natural Science, contained seeds of perplexity. While delectable to his immediate students, the seeds never found fertile ground amongst subsequent philosophers.

Figure 1.11  Acropolis
We have something of Anaxagoras' teaching on substance from fragments of his treatise which survived the ravages of time. One sentence encapsulates his theory: "In everything there is a portion of everything else, except of mind; and in some things there is mind also." Imagine a collection of things, for example a hair, fig, rock, and flame. Each contains seeds (sperma) of the other-- and everything else. "For how could hair come from what is not hair, or flesh from what is not flesh?" Each particular thing comes into being only as one type of seed or another comes to dominate the mix-- of every thing's seeds-- in a particular substance. Unfortunately, Anaxagoras had no way to provide physical evidence for his theory. "Because of the weakness of our senses we are not able to judge the truth." We can only judge the master's reasoning which, of course, is empowered within his organic substance by seeds of mind. Lesser animals and plants, insofar as they have sentience, also manifest seeds of mind.

Lest the sceptic demand to be told how seeds of all things could fit into a grain of sand as well as a large tree, Anaxagoras would explain: "In everything there is always a multiplicity of different ingredients; and there are as many ingredients separable from the lesser as there are ingredients separable from the greater." How many? As many as you like! An obvious question then arises. How small is each seed that they should all of every kind fit into the smallest thing? Given the previous answer on quantity, the question of magnitude is just as easily answered: "In the small there is no least, but always a lesser; for being cannot be defined by reference to not-being. Likewise there is always something bigger than what is big. The large and the small are thus equal in amount. And each thing taken from its own standpoint is large and small simultaneously." How small is each seed? As small as you like!

The question of quality was, we suppose, answered by the quantitative predominance of some seeds over others, each seed manifesting its own particular quality. Thus "composite things contain many ingredients of the very greatest variety--the seeds of everything, having all kinds of characteristics, colors, and ways of affecting the sensitivities." Presumably, particular seeds come to dominate in a particular object by separation. "When all things were together, before any separating had taken place, not even any color was discernible. This was because of the utter mixture of all things-- of moist with dry, hot with cold, bright with dark." According to Anaxagoras, our present cosmos developed step-by-step from the primordial mixture, irreversibly.

In the beginning: "All things were together, unlimited both in number and in smallness; for smallness too was unlimited. And when all things were together none of them could be distinguished because of their smallness." Beyond this, pure Mind (Nous) alone existed. "And Mind took charge of the cosmic situation, so that the universe proceeded to rotate from the very beginning. At first the rotation was small, but by now it extends over a larger space, and it will extend over a yet larger one. Both the things that are mingled and those that are separated and individuated are all known by Mind."

Anaxagoras went on to explain that the vortex of rotary movement encompassed the cosmos, including "the revolving movements of the stars, of the sun and moon, and of the air and aether as they are being separated off. It was the rotary movement that caused the separation-- a separation of the dense from the rare, the hot from the cold, the bright from the dark, and the dry from the moist. When Mind first set things in motion, there began a process of separation in the moving mass; and as things were thus moving and separating, the process of separation was greatly increased by the rotary movement. ... The dense, the moist, the cold, and the dark came together here where the earth now is; while the rare, the warm, the dry, and the bright departed towards the farthest region of the aether." As the motion initiated by Mind fulfills its purpose, all the things familiar to the senses became properly separated and "when separation has taken place each kind of entity is fixed in amount."

Beyond all this, "it may be that the separating and individuating process goes on not only in our own world but elsewhere too." In regard to such other worlds, we "should recognize the possibility that men may have been formed [from the substrate of seeds] as well as other organisms that possess souls; and that such men may perhaps dwell in cities and cultivate their fields just as we do, and that they have their sun and moon and other heavenly bodies as we do, and that their earth yields them vegetable life of all kinds, the most useful of which they harvest and take home to supply their needs."

As his career developed, Anaxagoras not only earned the distinction of being the first philosopher to flourish as a teacher in Athens; he was also the first to be condemned by vested authority for ungodly statements. Or so the story goes about the aging philosopher's forced retirement:

Anaxagoras was well known for teaching that the Moon and Sun, revered as Divine by the religious, were composed of mundane substance. The Selene body was, according to the philosopher, merely an earthy reflector of sunlight. Anaxagoras was not the first to make that claim. His assertion that Helios was merely a molten rock-- like all the other stars-- was perhaps more original and, as an integral feature of his cosmology, more threatening to public opinion. Writing from extant sources some five centuries later, Diogenes Laertius repeats alternate versions of the tale appended to the likely fact that pious Athenians brought charges against Anaxagoras. He was either tried solely for impiety or for treason as well. The charge of treason was said to have been politically motivated by enemies of Pericles. In either case, Pericles was the old philosopher's champion at trial but failed to gain his acquital. Anaxagoras was either condemned to exile and lived out his life in dignity, or he was condemned to death. In the latter version of the story, Pericles got the sentence amended to exile but his aging teacher was so demoralized by the ordeal that he committed suicide soon after.
Democritus
On the northern coast of the Aegean Sea, the Ionian city of Abdera was in ancient times hardly a world away from Athens. Yet that outpost of Greek polity in the barbarous lands of Thrace is only remembered for the sake of several notable philosophers and their influence in Athens. Protagoras, the eminent sophist mentioned only briefly below with Socrates, may have been born in Abdera circa 490 BCE (give or take a decade). More importantly, Abdera was the purported place in which Democritus was born (circa 460 BCE) and the location of a school established (circa 430-420 BCE) by Leucippus, who was said to have been born in Miletus. 

Little is known nowadays of Leucippus except that he taught Democritus the doctrine which became known as atomism and left one sentence to posterity: "Nothing happens at random; whatever comes about is by rational necessity." (DK Fragment 2) This was the world's first clear statement of strict determinism, although subsequent materialists would be unable to bolster it with experimental evidence for another two millenia.

Figure 1.12
According to Diogenes Laertius writing in the third century CE, Leucippus studied under Zeno of Elea before developing his own radically different doctrine. While the Eleatics insisted upon the immobile permanence of Being and the absurdity of empty spaces (i.e., not-Being) within the cosmos, Leucippus explained the cosmos as a matter of tiny indivisibles in perpetual motion through the void. In the Greek tongue, the word for 'indivisible' was atomos and thus the word for the smallest whole particle of matter came down to us as 'atom'. With an eye to Eleatic doctrine, the atomists were careful to delineate the void as any place simply without atoms-- not not-Being but rather, any space to and from which atoms moved-- and insisted that atoms alone had true Being. "[I]n reality there are only atoms and the void." (DK Fragment 7) By this tactic, they hoped to reaffirm the common perception of motion (or, more generally, change in appearance) and restore its concept to rational apprehension while demoting not-Being as an issue in physics.

While Leucippus left little record of his thoughts, Democritus published at least nine treatises on ethics and twelve concerning physics. Unfortunately, all were lost to us over the centuries. What little we have directly of Democritus is contained in a few sentences quoted by later writers from manuscripts extant in the classical period. The nearest general statements of Democritus' position in his own era are given by Aristotle and Theophrastus, the scholar who succeeded Aristotle as head of the Lyceum (described briefly below). The closest thing we have to a detailed statement of the atomist perspective is given by Lucretius in De rerum natura published circa 55 BCE, a single copy of which survived more or less intact down to our time. The content of that manuscript will be discussed in Chapter Three.

As Diogenes tells the story, Democritus "met Anaxagoras who was forty years his senior [but] disparaged Anaxagoras' theories of the cosmos and of the mind. There was a lack of sympathy between them amounting to hostility." We might suppose that the atomist theory was more specific and accessible than the Anaxagoran doctrine in its account of substantial phenomena yet had to compete for intellectual attention in its marketing of a universal substrate replete with miniscule components, i.e., atoms vs. seeds. Diogenes goes on to say that Democritus "despised fame, and when he visited Athens he did not make himself known to Socrates [who was about the same age as Democritus], although knowing well enough who he was." In an account of his travels around the Aegean and Mediterranean Seas, including Egypt where he stayed for several years, Democritus is said to have written that

"I am the most widely traveled man of all my contemporaries, and have pursued inquiries in the most distant places; I have visited more countries and climes than anyone else, and have listened to the teachings of more learned men."
In his own teaching, Democritus validated sensory perception while articulating a deeper sense of reality by distinguishing two types of knowledge, one 'obscure' and the other 'genuine'. (Importantly for us, both types of knowledge are useful and, as Heraclitus might have said, either type only works best in dialogue with the other.) In his own words,
"Obscure knowledge includes everything that is given by [the five senses]; whereas genuine knowledge is something quite distinct from this. Whenever obscure knowledge can no longer [gain sense of] the objects because of their smallness [then we must resort to] a finer means of knowledge."
In other words, we need consider atomic structure theoretically to obtain the deepest knowledge. "The truth is that what we meet with perceptually is nothing reliable, for it shifts its character according to the [object's] dispositions, influences, and confrontations." The sensible object varies in appearance as the prevailing conditions effect the insensible atoms, driving exterior atoms to effect the atoms within an object under scrutiny and thus changing its appearance. "By this criterion man must learn that he is divorced from reality." (The rhetorical use of 'divorce' would seem to have radicalized the debate yet, as Lucretius later states the case for atomism, our knowledge of atoms may readily enable a better union with our senses to enrich our perceptions.)

We are told by Aristotle that Democritus conceives atoms "as so small as to elude our senses, but as having all sorts of forms, shapes, and different sizes. Treating them as elements he conceives of them as combining to produce visible and otherwise perceptible objects." Coming into contact during their unceasing motions, the atoms "tend to get ensnarled and interlocked." The atoms "fit snugly and so catch firm hold of one another; for some are scalene while others are sharply hooked, some are concave, others convex, and there are numerous other differences. [Democritus'] theory is that they cling together and remain in certain combinations until they are shaken apart and separated by outside forces." The apparent differences between one type of material and another are explained by the atomists as the result of the component atoms differing. According to Aristotle:

"These differences, they say, are three-- shape and order and position. For they say the real is differentiated only by 'rhythm', and 'inter-contact' and 'turning'; and of these rhythm is shape, inter-contact is order, and turning is position; for A differs from N in shape, AN for NA in order, [horizontal H] from H in position." (Metaphysics, I.4.985b15)
Theophrastus comments on the atomist explanation of the qualitative differences we perceive between one substance and another:
  • "Differences of heaviness and lightness are explained by Democritus as ultimately differences of size. For if we could get down to atomic units, we would see that [since every atom is absolutely solid] the only standard of an atom's weight must be its size. In the case of compounds, on the contrary, two bodies of the same size might be of different weights; for the body containing more emptiness would be lighter, while that containing less would be heavier."
  • The qualities of hard and soft manifest in a substance are explained as a function of the constituent atoms' packing, those packed more loosely creating a softer substance. Such qualitative differences are illustrated by two lumps of metal: "[Although iron is harder than lead, lead is heavier than iron. That is because the iron is of uneven composition, and its empty spaces are more numerous and bigger although the particles are more condensed in some places than in others. But its average of empty spaces exceeds that of lead."


Some apparent qualities are explained as the effect which certain atoms have as they impinge upon our senses. "[S]weet consists of atomic figures that are rounded and not too hard; it softens the body by its gentle action." On the other hand, anything tasting sour "is composed of atoms that are angular, tiny, thin, and twisted." Hot and cold are explained as "merely a matter of configuration" and, given two samples of the same substance, "whatever has most empty spaces amongst its atoms is most heated." Speaking generally of external objects, "What we experience as qualitative change within ourselves is the effect of incoming atomic configurations being massed together so as to produce intensity of effect. What is massed together [on entering our sense organs] prevails [as a conscious experience], while what is widely diffused is imperceptible."

The atomists explained the phenomena of earth, air, and water in terms of their component atoms, as well as ascribing very fine atoms to the phenomena of light. With heat as described above and light, the atomists thus explained fire.

Comparatively speaking from a modern perspective, we might suppose that the atomist theory superceded Empedocles, as well as Thales and Anaximenes. Anaximander's aperion would seem to have fallen to the wayside, along with Anaxagoras' sperma, since the more intellectually accessible atoms would seem to have come to the foreground of discussion. Furthermore, Parmenides principle of Being was respected without recourse to not-Being and Heraclitus' notion of perpetual change was exonerated, since the large-scale motion and small-scale shuffling of component atoms was vital to the ever-changing appearances of all things. If the early history of discourse on the nature of material substance could be said (by us, as moderns) to have exhibited an evolution of thought which verged on the truth of the matter with Democritus, his contemporaries took atomism as just another theory. Without means of proof or adequate demonstration, the sense of the matter under investigation soon became obscured by the immaterial considerations of subsequent thinkers.

7PREV   CONTENTS   NEXT8